Yes, you put on rust preventive. Yet, some parts seem more prone to rust than others.
PMPA members rely on the members only Listserves to collectively solve problems and to advance everyone’s knowledge of the craft.
So it was no surprise to me at the end of July to see a post on PMPA’s Quality Listserve asking if some steels are more prone to rusting than others.
That same morning I emptied 45 pints of water out of the basement dehumidifier…
I counted six member company respondents to the original question, including one respondent with a specific example. Plus PMPA staff contributed a reply. This is the value of PMPA Member only Listserves. Every respondent is in the trade, and their experience and expertise is known- no Aliases.
So what are some of the factors that can contribute to your regular carbon or alloy steel parts rusting- Here is a brief summary of the factors brought up:
Steel related factors
- The steels’ electrode potential
- Chemical composition- unless a self-healing film is generated by the alloying additions, more complicated chemistry means more likely to rust;
- Chemically non-homogeneous surface – (segregation)
- Physically non-homogenous surface – texture, pits and cracks and crevices
Processing related factors
- Is a film existing from prior operations (scale from mill rolling, oil from machining etc.) to prevent permeation of Oxygen and water-and is it intact?
- Is there a significant difference in section thickness?
- Is the part or places on the part highly stressed? (Stress can help accelerate the reaction)
- Were other substances deposited on the material which could accelerate or inhibit rusting (Metal fines, salts, carbon ‘smut’ , acids or bases)?
- Does a result of the process leave cracks crevices, or other similar features?
- Solution in contact (presence and type)
- Hydrogen ion availability (pH) of the moisture
- Oxygen level
- Other ions species, their type and electroactivity
- Flow or exchange rate of solution (or stagnation)
- Degree of wetting
- Temperature / Humidity time of year
- Location: inside, controlled climate, or in transit
- Is their cyclic stress?
Finally in the case where two or more dissimilar metals are in contact ( Even welded) the electrochemical potentials of these being different will result in the most anodic (Active) (A= anode = active) will be corroded by the most noble (Noble= Not as reactive).
Poor Engineering Factor
- Dissimilar metals contacting. (Galvanic corrosion)
Of course, all of these factors can interact, and I note that the rust question is a little early this year, it usually arrived about mid- August most years when I was handling claims at the steel company.
This is the meat of the PMPA Listserve discussion. What we didn’t provide here in this post were the specific tips, tricks, product recommendations and other insights that some poster’s shared regarding ther packaging and rust preventive application to prevent Rust from occurring in various situations.
PMPA Listserves- Advancing member competitiveness with each question asked.
The type of rust preventative fluid is important. For example, is it intended for the metal alloy, application method (spray or dip) and storage conditions (indoor/outdoor)?
Finally, the surface cleanliness is another major contributing factor. Dirt greatly increases surface area and rust can be transferred from the swarf/fines/dirt to the surface of the part.
Product Manager, Fuchs Lubricants Co.
Thanks for your comment Jonathan. CArruyover of dirt and swarf is indeed a concern as well.